AI and your rights under the Commerce Act
If a business uses artificial intelligence (AI), it must still follow competition law. Businesses cannot avoid their legal responsibilities simply because decisions were made by an AI system, algorithm or automated tool.
The Commission's role
-
The Commission is responsible for enforcing the Commerce Act and can investigate and take enforcement action relating to restrictive trade practices.
-
The Commission does not regulate artificial intelligence (AI) tools or AI systems. We do not oversee or enforce laws specifically relating to the development or use of AI.
AI and your rights under the Commerce Act
If a business uses artificial intelligence (AI), it must still follow competition law. Businesses cannot avoid their legal responsibilities simply because decisions were made by an AI system, algorithm or automated tool.
How AI affect competition
AI can help businesses set prices, recommend products, target customers, and make decisions. Used responsibly, AI can benefit consumers through improved products, services and efficiency.
However, if AI is used in ways that reduce competition, consumers could face higher prices, less choice, and fewer opportunities for innovation.
How AI use could affect consumers
Businesses working together on prices
The Commerce Act prohibits competitors from agreeing to fix prices, divide customers or markets, or limit supply. Businesses cannot avoid responsibility simply because pricing or business decisions were made by AI systems. If AI tools are used in a way that reduces competition between businesses, this may breach the law.
Powerful businesses gaining an unfair advantage
Some large businesses have access to vast amounts of data and sophisticated AI systems, giving them significant market power.
The law prevents businesses with substantial market power from using that power in ways that substantially reduce competition.
Examples could include:
Favouring their own products
A large online platform may use AI-powered search results or recommendations to promote its own products ahead of competitors' products, regardless of what consumers are actually looking for.
Making it harder to use competing services
A business may bundle AI products with other services in a way that makes it difficult for customers to choose competing products.
Using pricing to push out competitors
A business may use AI-powered pricing tools to set prices in ways that make it difficult for rivals to compete or for new businesses to enter the market.
Large businesses buying potential competitors
The Commerce Act can prevent mergers or acquisitions that are likely to substantially reduce competition. This includes situations where an established business acquires a smaller innovative company, technology, data asset, or AI capability to remove a future competitor from the market.
What happens if a business breaks the law
Businesses that break the Commerce Act can face significant penalties.
For serious anti-competitive conduct, individuals can be fined up to $500,000 for each breach, and face 7 years in prison for cartel conduct. Businesses can be fined the greater of:
- $10 million
- three times the value of any commercial gain from the breach
- 10% of the business's annual turnover.
Each separate breach may result in a separate penalty.
Next steps
Concerned about anti-competitive behaviour
If you have information about conduct that may harm competition, you can report it to the Commerce Commission by emailing us at contact@comcom.govt.nz.