Algorithmic Collusion and the Commerce Act
Many businesses use algorithms, AI, machine learning, and automated pricing tools to help make decisions. These technologies can improve efficiency, reduce costs, and help businesses respond more quickly to market changes but they can also create competition law risks.
The Commission's role
-
The Commission is responsible for enforcing the Commerce Act and can investigate and take enforcement action relating to restrictive trade practices.
-
The Commission does not regulate artificial intelligence (AI) tools or AI systems. We do not oversee or enforce laws specifically relating to the development or use of AI.
Using AI and algorithms in your business
Many businesses use algorithms, AI, machine learning, and automated pricing tools to help make decisions. These technologies can improve efficiency, reduce costs, and help businesses respond more quickly to market changes but they can also create competition law risks.
Using AI or algorithms does not change your obligations under the Commerce Act. If technology is used to support cartel conduct or other anti-competitive behaviour, the businesses involved may still be liable.
What is algorithmic collusion?
Algorithmic collusion happens when algorithms or AI systems help competitors coordinate in a way that reduces competition. This could include:
-
competitors agreeing on prices and using algorithms to put that agreement into effect
-
using a shared pricing platform or software provider that enables competitors to exchange sensitive information
-
algorithms that reduce uncertainty about how competitors will behave
-
AI systems that produce coordinated outcomes that lessen competition.
The Commerce Act applies to AI and algorithms
The cartel rules in section 30 of the Commerce Act apply whether decisions are made by people, software, algorithms, or AI systems. Businesses cannot avoid responsibility by handing pricing or other competitive decisions to technology.
A breach of the cartel provisions can result in significant penalties, including substantial financial penalties for businesses and, in some cases, criminal liability for individuals.
Common risk areas
Using algorithms to implement a cartel
Competition law concerns can arise where competitors agree on prices, customers, territories, output, or bidding behaviour, and then use algorithms to monitor or enforce that agreement.
An algorithm is simply another way of carrying out cartel conduct. Automating the behaviour does not make it lawful.
Sharing sensitive information
Risks can also arise when algorithms use competitors' current or future pricing, customer, output, or strategic information.
Sharing information that reduces uncertainty between competitors can breach competition law, whether the information is used by people or by automated systems.
Using the same platform or software provider
Businesses should be cautious when using common pricing platforms, software tools, data intermediaries, or AI services.
If a platform allows competitors to share commercially sensitive information, or generates recommendations using competitors' confidential information, competition law concerns may arise.
Using an independent technology provider does not automatically protect a business from liability.
Autonomous AI systems
Some advanced AI systems can make decisions with limited human oversight. Research suggests that, in some situations, autonomous systems may learn behaviours that result in coordinated market outcomes.
Businesses should understand how these systems operate and ensure appropriate oversight is in place.
What the Commerce Commission looks for
The Commerce Commission supports the use of AI and algorithmic tools where they deliver benefits for consumers and businesses. Our focus is on conduct that harms competition, not the use of technology itself.
We may investigate conduct where algorithms or AI systems facilitate cartel behaviour or other anti-competitive outcomes.
If you are concerned about potential competition law issues, you should seek legal advice and consider engaging with the Commission early.
What businesses can do
Businesses should consider the following safeguards when adopting algorithmic tools and AI systems:
Make decisions independently
Ensure pricing, customer targeting, output, and other competitive decisions remain independent from competitors. AI systems should not be designed or configured to coordinate with competitors.
Do not use competitors' sensitive information
Avoid training or calibrating systems using competitors' confidential pricing, customer, output, or strategic information unless legally permitted. Put controls in place to prevent accidental use of sensitive competitor information.
Update your compliance programme
Ensure your competition law compliance programme covers AI and algorithm-related risks. Train staff to recognise and report potential issues.
Check third-party tools carefully
Before adopting pricing software, AI tools, or algorithms from a third party, understand:
-
what data the system uses
-
whether competitor information contributes to outputs
-
how recommendations are generated
-
whether data from different businesses is separated
-
what safeguards are in place to prevent anti-competitive outcomes.
Maintain human oversight
Staff should understand how systems work and regularly review outputs. Human oversight should involve meaningful review and challenge, not simply accepting recommendations.
Review systems regularly
Regularly audit:
-
algorithm design and objectives
-
data sources
-
pricing outcomes
-
interactions with competitors
-
information-sharing arrangements
-
compliance controls.
Keep good records
Maintain records of:
-
how systems are designed and governed
-
data sources
-
competition law risk assessments
-
audit findings
-
decisions to adopt or modify AI and pricing tools.
Good documentation can help demonstrate that commercial decisions were made independently.
Next steps
Need more information?
This guidance reflects the Commerce Commission's current views and is not a substitute for legal advice.
If you have information about possible breaches of the laws we enforce, contact us at contact@comcom.govt.nz.