On 9 September 2005, the Commission published in the New Zealand Gazette its intention to make a declaration of control under Part 4A of the Commerce Act 1986 (now repealed), in respect of electricity distribution services supplied by Unison Networks Limited (Unison). Unison is a distribution business that supplies distribution services to electricity consumers in the Hawke's Bay, Rotorua and Taupo regions.
Subsequently, on 31 August 2006, the Commission received an administrative settlement offer from Unison. Having reviewed Unison's offer, on 29 November 2006 the Commission published its draft decision not to declare control of Unison.
On 11 May 2007, the Commission issued its final determination to accept the administrative settlement offer provided by Unison. As part of the settlement, Unison reduced its average electricity line charges, and rebalanced its charges to consumers. Unison remained subject to the existing price-path and quality thresholds set by the Commission under Part 4A until 31 March 2009.
Documents
Commission's Reports and Documents
(16 documents)
- Regulation of Electricity Lines Businesses - Targeted Control Regime - Reasons for Not Declaring Control - Unison - 11 May 2007 PDF (514 KB)
- Regulation of Electricity Lines Businesses - Targeted Control Regime - Draft Decision: Reasons for Not Declaring Control of Unison - 9 November 2006 PDF (424 KB)
- Parsons Brinckerhoff - Review of 2006 Asset Management Plan - Unison Networks - October 2006 PDF (474 KB)
- Unison - Submission on Settlement Proposal - 1 September 2006 PDF (792 KB)
- Unison - Settlement Proposal - 13 September 2006 PDF (113 KB)
- Unison - Settlement Proposal - 18 October 2006 PDF (63 KB)
- Public Meeting to Discuss Intention to Declare Control of Unison PDF (18 KB)
- Intention to Declare Control: Unison Conference - Stage 1 - Timetable - 17-18 November 2005 PDF (27 KB)
- Unison Intention to Declare Control Conference Dates and Process - 1 November 2005 PDF (32 KB)
- Regulation of Electricity Lines Businesses - Targeted Control Regime - Intention to Declare Control - Unison - 9 September 2005 PDF (570 KB)
- Unison - Stage 2 Inquiry Disaggregated Spreadsheet Microsoft Excel Spreadsheet (454 KB)
- Martin Lally - The Weighted Average Cost of Capital for Electricity Lines Businesses - 8 September 2005 PDF (561 KB)
- Regulation of Electricity Lines Businesses - Targeted Control Regime - Assessment and Inquiry Guidelines - 19 October 2004 PDF (342 KB)
- Unison Intention to Declare Control 9 September 2005 Aggregate Model Microsoft Excel Spreadsheet (432 KB)
- Unison Intention to Declare Control Conference Stage II PDF (42 KB)
- Unison Intention to Declare Control Unison Main Model PDF (33 KB)
Cross Submissions on Draft Decision Not to Declare Control - 11 December 2006
(3 documents)
- Consumer Coallition on Energy - Cross Submission on Unison's draft settlement - 11 December 2006 PDF (55 KB)
- MEUG - Cross Submission on Unison's Draft Settlement Proposal - 11 December 2006 PDF (51 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission on Regulation of Electricity Lines Businesses - Targeted Control Regime - Draft Decision: Reasons for Not Declaring Control of Unison - 11 December 2006 PDF (216 KB)
Submissions on Draft Decision Not to Declare Control - 29 November 2006
(6 documents)
- Consumer Coallition on Energy - CC93 Recommend an Amended Settlement Counter-Offer to Unison - 29 November 2006 PDF (59 KB)
- MEUG - Submission on Unison's Draft Settlement Proposal - 29 November 2006 PDF (63 KB)
- Mighty River Power - Submission on Draft Decision: Reasons for Not Declaring Control - Unison Networks - 29 November 2006 PDF (334 KB)
- Orion - Submission on Draft Decision: Reasons for Not Declaring Control Unison - 29 November 2006 PDF (73 KB)
- Powerco - Unison Post-Breach Inquiry - 29 November 2006 PDF (48 KB)
- Vector - Submission on Reasons for Not Declaring Control of Unison - 29 November 2006 PDF (108 KB)
Unison Interim Undertaking - 14 March 2006
(1 documents)
Cross-Submissions on Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 21 December 2005
(27 documents)
- AECT - Intention to Declare Control on Unison Networks: AECT Cross Submission - 22 December 2005 PDF (100 KB)
- Ewing Robertson - Cross Submission on Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 22 December 2005 PDF (53 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission on Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 28 November 2005 PDF (13 KB)
- Grey Power - Cross Submission on Intention to Declare Control over Unison - 16 December 2005 PDF (82 KB)
- Hastings District Council - Cross Submission on Unison Intention to Declare Control - 22 December 2005 PDF (27 KB)
- Mighty River Power - Cross Submission on Consultation Paper - Intention to Declare Control - Unison Networks - 22 December 2005 PDF (94 KB)
- Orion - Cross Submission on Intention to Declare Control of Unison Networks - 22 December 2005 PDF (64 KB)
- P Ward - Cross Submission on Regarding their Intention to Declare Control of Unison PDF (13 KB)
- Powerco - Unison Post-Breach Inquiry - 21 December 2005 PDF (149 KB)
- Robin Gwynn - Cross Submission on Intention to Declare Control of Unison - December 2005 PDF (50 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 2F - Unison CRA Cross Submission PDF (199 KB)
- Transpower - Targeted Control Regime: Cross Submission following the Unison conference - 5 December 2005 PDF (78 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission on Regulation of Electricity Lines Business - Targeted Control Regime - Intention to Declare Control - January 2005 PDF (172 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 1 - Response to Laminex Submission PDF (22 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 1A - Reapplication of ex-gratia discount PDF (37 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Attachment 1B - Part 1 PDF (22 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 1A Laminex PDF (11 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 2 - Information Requests PDF (25 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 2A - Inquiry Costs PDF (9.5 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 2C - Sponsorship Summary PDF (13 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 2D - Unison PWC Cross Submission PDF (68 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 2E - Unison Leveredge Cross Submission PDF (214 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 2F - Unison CRA Cross Submission PDF (199 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 3 - Simpson Grierson Memo PDF (515 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 4 - Dellwind Pty Comments PDF (32 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 2B - Regulatory Costs PDF (9.9 KB)
- Unison - Cross Submission Appendix 5 - Lexecon Additional Submission PDF (82 KB)
Unison Conference Stage I
(4 documents)
- Intention to Declare Control: Unison Conference - Transcript - 17 November 2005 PDF (341 KB)
- Intention to Declare Control: Unison Conference - Transcript - 18 November 2005 PDF (179 KB)
- Mighty River Power - Oral Submission on Consultation Paper - Regulation of Electricity Lines Businesses - Targeted Control Regime - Intention to Declare Control - Unison - 17-18 November 2005 PDF (104 KB)
- PowerNet - Presentation - Submission on Intention to Declare Control on Unison - 16 Novemebr 2005 Microsoft Powerpoint Presentation (148 KB)
Unison Conference Stage II
(13 documents)
- Intention to Declare Control: Unison - Open Session - Transcript - 5 December 2005 PDF (440 KB)
- Intention to Declare Control: Unison - Closed Session - Transcript - 5 December 2005 PDF (83 KB)
- Intention to Declare Control of Unison Conference - Transcript - 6 December 2005 PDF (405 KB)
- Intention to Declare Control: Unison Networks - Conference-Stage 2 Timetable - 5-6 December 2005 PDF (42 KB)
- Unison - Intention to Declare Control Conference Presentation - 5-6 December 2005 PDF (164 KB)
- Unison - Intention to Declare Control Conference Presentation - Overview and Challenges - 5 December 2005 PDF (918 KB)
- Unison - Benchmark Economics Presentation - Intention to Declare Control Conference - Network Cost Structure Study - December 2005 PDF (340 KB)
- Unison - PWC Presentation - Optimised Deprival Valuations in the context of a Post Breach Inquiry for Unison - 5-6 December 2005 PDF (1.5 MB)
- Unison - LeverEdge Presentation - Efficient Investment of Renewal Capital - 5 December 2005 PDF (433 KB)
- Unison - CRA Presentation - Review of Intention to Declare Control of Unison - December 2005 PDF (217 KB)
- Lexecon - Gustavo Bamberger Presentation - Review of Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 6 December 2005 PDF (31 KB)
- Unison - Simpson Grierson - Unison Control Inquiry - Legal Issues - 6 December 2005 PDF (56 KB)
- Unison - Conference Presentation - Intention to Declare Control - Unison - 5-6 December 2005 PDF (75 KB)
Unison Conference Stage III
(5 documents)
- Unison - Public Meeting to Discuss Intention to Declare Control of Unison Notice PDF (24 KB)
- Unison - Intention to Declare Control of Unison Conference Presentation - 14-15 December 2005 PDF (135 KB)
- Intention to Declare Control: Unison Conference - Rotorua Conference - Transcript - 14 December 2005 PDF (125 KB)
- Intention to Declare Control: Unison Conference - Taupo Conference - Transcript - 14 December 2005 PDF (135 KB)
- Intention to Declare Control: Unison Conference - Napier Conference - Transcript - 15 December 2005 PDF (315 KB)
Submissions on Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 21 October 2005
(64 documents)
- AECT - Submission on Intention to Declare Control on Unison Networks - 21 October 2005 PDF (187 KB)
- Electricity Networks - Submission in Response to Report on Intention to Declare Control of Unison Networks' services - 28 October 2005 PDF (53 KB)
- Grey Power - Submission on Intention to Control Unison Prices - 5 October 2005 PDF (47 KB)
- Hastings District Council - Submission on Unison Intention to Declare Control - October 2005 PDF (59 KB)
- Hawke's Bay Power Consumers' Trust - Submission on its intention to declare control over Unison Networks - 26 October 2005 PDF (429 KB)
- Hawke's Bay Regional Council - Submission on Intention to Declare Control - 20 October 2005 PDF (31 KB)
- The Laminex Group - Submission on Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 10 October 2005 PDF (33 KB)
- MEUG - Submission on Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 21 October 2005 PDF (30 KB)
- Marlborough Lines - Submission on Regulation of Electricity Lines Businesses Targeted Control Regime Intention to Declare Control - Unison - 1 November 2005 PDF (190 KB)
- Mighty River Power Submission on Commission's Price Control of Unison 26 October 2005 PDF (246 KB)
- Mighty River Power - MJA Report - Regulation of Electricity Lines Businesses Target Control Regime - Comments on Cost of Capital - 20 October 2005 PDF (277 KB)
- Orion - Submission on Intention to Declare Control of Unison Networks - 28 October 2005 PDF (410 KB)
- PF Olsen and Co - Rotorua Electricity Network Provision - 11 October 2005 PDF (58 KB)
- Powerco - Submission on Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 21 October 2005 PDF (107 KB)
- Powerco - WACC Issues in Targeted Control Regime, Intention to Declare Control, Unison - October 2005 PDF (209 KB)
- PowerNet - Submission on Proposed Changes to the Intention to Declare Control on Unison - 25 October 2005 PDF (94 KB)
- Rotorua Chamber of Commerce - Rotorua Electricity Network Provision - 26 October 2005 PDF (62 KB)
- Red Stag Timber - Rotorua Electricity Network Provision - 31 October 2005 PDF (38 KB)
- Rotorua District Council - Rotorua Electricity Network Provision - 21 October 2005 PDF (66 KB)
- Taupo Chamber of Commerce - Unison - 20 October 2005 PDF (16 KB)
- Taupo District Council - Submission to Notice 2005: Commerce Act (Intention to declare control: Unison Networks) - 21 October 2005 PDF (184 KB)
- Powerco - Allen Consulting - Regulation of Electricity Lines Businesses: Intention to Declare Cntrol on Unison - October 2005 PDF (166 KB)
- TelstraClear - Price Control Unison Networks - 21 OCtober 2005 PDF (34 KB)
- Transpower - Targeted Control Regime: Intention to Declare Control Unison - 21 October 2005 PDF (94 KB)
- Unison - Regulation of Electricity Lines Business - Targeted Control Regime Intention to Declare Control - October 2005 PDF (396 KB)
- Unison - Appendix 1 - Lexecon - Submission of Gustavo Bamberger for Unison Networks PDF (145 KB)
- Appendix B - CRA Report - Review of Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 28 October 2005 PDF (731 KB)
- Appendix B - CRA Report - Appendicies PDF (368 KB)
- Unison - Appendix C - A Critique of the use of WACC as a Parameter in Price Regulation of a Company - 21 October 2005 PDF (98 KB)
- Appendix D - Volume 1 - Unison - Benchmark Economics Report - Electricity Distribution Networks: Cost Structure Analysis - October 2005 PDF (791 KB)
- Appendix D - Volume 2 - Unison - Benchmark Economics Report - Electricity Distribution Networks: Cost Structure Analysis - Technical Appendix - October 2005 PDF (252 KB)
- Unison - Appendix E - Optimised Deprival Valuations in the Context of a Post Breach Inquiry for Unison - 21 October 2005 PDF (139 KB)
- Unison - Appendix F - Electricity Lines Business Disclosures Comparative Performance of Unison - 21 October 2005 PDF (134 KB)
- Unison - Appendix H - Report on the Tax Implications of: Regulation of Electricity Lines Businesses Target Control Regime Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 21 October 2005 PDF (133 KB)
- Appendix G - Unison - PWC Letter - Intention to Declare Control - 27 October 2005 PDF (84 KB)
- Appendix I - Unison - High Level Review of Unison's Asset Management - October 2005 PDF (272 KB)
- Appendix J - Unison - Report on Relationship between Asset Age and Failure Rates on Utility Network Assets - October 2005 PDF (52 KB)
- Appendix K - Unison - Assessment of Prudent Network Reinforcement Capital Expenditure - October 2005 PDF (52 KB)
- Appendix L - Unison - LeverEdge Report - Efficient Investment of Renewal Capital - 21 October 2005 PDF (242 KB)
- Appendix M - Unison - Asia Pacific Report - The Impact of Regulatory Pricing Control on Borrowing Arrangements - 25 October 2005 PDF (246 KB)
- Appendix N - Unison - Overhead Line to Underground Cabe Research PDF (228 KB)
- United Gooder - Unison Networks - 13 October 2005 PDF (105 KB)
- Vector - Submission on Draft Decisions Relating to Implementation of the Regulatory Asset Base Valuation Methodology - 17 November 2005 PDF (57 KB)
- Vector - LECG Report - Comment on the method used to Assess Relative Prices of Unison's Sub-networks - 25 October 2005 PDF (272 KB)
- Vector - LECG Report - Calculation of Income Tax in the Unison Inquiry - 25 October 2005 PDF (249 KB)
- Colin H Ashton - Submission on Control of Unison Networks - 10 October 2005 PDF (85 KB)
- J A Camp - Letter in support of Unison - 7 October 2005 PDF (42 KB)
- Ann Dixon - Submission on Intention to Declare Control of Unison - 18 October 2005 PDF (656 KB)
- Marie Dunningham - Submission on Proposed Control of Unison Networks - 18 October 2005 PDF (16 KB)
- D G Fuller and R W Fuller - Letter in Support of Unison - 7 October 2005 PDF (41 KB)
- Little Flying Duck - Unison Intention to Declare Control - 17 October 2005 PDF (48 KB)
- John Herbert - Submission on Unison - 28 November 2005 PDF (42 KB)
- C Leggat - Letter in Support of Unison - 7 October 2005 PDF (40 KB)
- F Lowe - Letter in support of Unison - 7 October 2005 PDF (41 KB)
- Fay Mair - Letter in Support of Unison - 7 October 2005 PDF (41 KB)
- R G Pebble - Letter in support of Unison - 7 October 2005 PDF (41 KB)
- H Rykers - Letter in support of Unison - 7 October 2005 PDF (42 KB)
- M Swenson - Letter in support of Unison - 10 October 2005 PDF (48 KB)
- J R Timpson - Letter in support of Unison - 7 October 2005 PDF (42 KB)
- Mighty River Power - Submission on Valuation of the Regulatory Asset Base - 10 November 2005 PDF (90 KB)
- H and V Van Vlerken - Letter in support of Unison - 7 October 2005 PDF (41 KB)
- P Ward - Final Written Submission on Intention to Declare Control - Unison - 20 October 2005 PDF (37 KB)
- Michael Waterson - Unison Post Breach Enquiry - 17 October 2005 PDF (90 KB)
- D S Whitfield - Private Submission on Unison Post-Breach Inquiry - 30 September 2004 PDF (76 KB)