Commerce Commission Website - Reports and Documents
   
Site Search
 
HomeThe CommissionMedia CentreThe LegislationPublicationsPublic RegistersFair TradingConsumer CreditBusiness CompetitionIndustry RegulationRegulatory Control AuthoritiesEnquiries & Complaints
Reports and Documents
» [Draft] Consultation Paper Commerce Commission’s Recommendation to Minister on Type of Regulation to Apply to Transpower
» Submissions on [Draft] Consultation Paper Commerce Commission’s Recommendation to Minister on Type of Regulation to Apply to Transpower
» Asset Planning and Forecast Information Disclosure for Airports Working Session - 18 February 2010
» Electricity Transmission Workshop - Material Presented
» Electricity Transmission Workshop
» Emerging Views Workshops
» Emerging Views Workshops - Transcripts
» Electricity Distribution and Gas Pipelines Workshop - 24 - 25 February 2010 - Post-workshop Submissions
» Electricity Distribution and Gas Pipelines Workshop - 24 - 25 February 2010 - Pre-workshop Submissions
» Airports Workshop - 17-18 February 2010 - Post-workshop Submissions
» Airports Workshop - 17 & 18 February 2010 - Pre-workshop Submissions
» Tax Workshop - 8 February 2010 - Post-workshop Submissions
» Tax Workshop - 8 February 2010 - Pre-workshop Submissions & Comments On Workshop Process
» Emerging Views Papers - 23 December 2009
» Submissions on Process for Transpower
» Update on Process for Input Methodologies and Airports Information Disclosure
» Update on Process for Transpower
» Gas - Default/Customised Price-Quality Regulation - Updated Process Paper - 9 October 2009
» Cross Submissions on Information Disclosure Discussion Paper in Respect of Airport Services - 2 November 2009
» Request for Cross Submissions on Information Disclosure Discussion Paper in Respect of Airport Services - 1 October 2009
» Questions for Cross Submissions
» Post Input Methodologies Conference Cross-Submissions
» Input Methodologies Conference Transcripts
» Information Disclosure Discussion Paper - 29 July 2009
» Submissions on Information Disclosure Discussion Paper - 29 July 2009
» Input Methodologies Discussion Paper - 19 June 2009
» Submissions on Input Methodologies Discussion Paper
» Cross Submissions on Input Methodologies Discussion Paper
» Revised Draft Guidelines on the Cost of Capital Paper - 19 June 2009
» Submissions on Revised Draft Guidelines on the Cost of Capital Paper
» Submissions on Transpower Process and Recommendation Paper
» Cross Submissions on Revised Draft Guidelines on the Cost of Capital Paper - 19 June 2009
» Transpower Process and Recommendation Paper - 19 June 2009
» Gas - Default/Customised Price-Quality Regulation - 24 July 2009
» Submissions on Gas - Default/Customised Price-Quality Regulation - 24 July 2009
» Part 4 Discussion Documents
» Cost of Capital Discussion Documents
» Cost of Capital Workshop Documents
» Submissions on Cost of Capital Workshop


[Draft] Consultation Paper Commerce Commission’s Recommendation to Minister on Type of Regulation to Apply to Transpower
[Draft] Consultation paper Commerce Commission’s Recommendation to Minister on type of regulation to apply to Transpower  (154 kb .pdf)

Top

Submissions on [Draft] Consultation Paper Commerce Commission’s Recommendation to Minister on Type of Regulation to Apply to Transpower
1. Contact  (25 kb .pdf)
2. ENA  (1409 kb .pdf)
3. Genesis  (44 kb .pdf)
4. Meridian Energy  (67 kb .pdf)
5. Mighty River Power  (66 kb .pdf)
6. Orion  (58 kb .pdf)
7. Transpower  (46 kb .pdf)
8. Vector Limited  (149 kb .pdf)

Top

Asset Planning and Forecast Information Disclosure for Airports Working Session - 18 February 2010
Asset Planning and Forecast Information Disclosure for Airports Working Session Papers  (55 kb .pdf)

Top

Electricity Transmission Workshop - Material Presented
Commission presentation on Capex - Large capex proposed long-term approach  (402 kb .PPT)
Commission presentation on Capex - Large capex proposed transition mechanisms  (352 kb .PPT)
Commission presentation on Capex - Minor capex proposed long-term approach  (460 kb .PPT)
Commission presentation on Capex - Minor capex proposed transition mechanisms  (349 kb .PPT)
Commission presentation on Capex - Proposed capex categories  (850 kb .PPT)
Commission presentation on New investment contracts  (248 kb .PPT)
Commission presentation on operating expenditure  (364 kb .PPT)
Commission presentation on possible safety-net facility  (271 kb .PPT)
Commission presentation on RCP1 transition year  (3398 kb .PPT)
John Scott - Presentation on Regulatory structures UK  (386 kb .PPT)
Merryn York - Capex Regulation in Australian  (2373 kb .PPT)
Transpower Presentation on Grid Maintenance Opex  (2978 kb .PPT)
Transpower presentation on New Investment Agreements  (247 kb .PPT)
Transpower Presentation on Quality  (402 kb .PPT)

Top

Electricity Transmission Workshop
Revised Agenda for Electricity Transmission Workshop - 3 March 2010  (27 kb .pdf)
Electricity Transmission Workshop Agenda and Participants  (36 kb .pdf)

Top

Emerging Views Workshops
Revised Invitation for EDB GPB Post-Workshop Submissions (5 March 2010).  (54 kb .pdf)
CPP Revised Workshop Notification - 24 February 2010  (33 kb .pdf)
  - CPP - Independent Verifier Framework and Terms of Reference  (236 kb .pdf)
  - Strata - CPP Information Requirements Draft Overview Paper  (1348 kb .PDF)
  - Strata - Quantitative Draft Electricity Distribution CPP Information Requirements  (302 kb .PDF)
  - Strata - Qualitative Draft Electricity Distribution CPP Information Requirements  (699 kb .PDF)
Electricity Transmission Emerging Views Workshop - Agenda (17 February 2010)  (126 kb .pdf)
Invitation for Transpower Post-Workshop Submissions  (28 kb .pdf)
EDB/GPB Input Methodologies Workshop Notification (16 February 2010)  (88 kb .pdf)
  - ENA - EDBs GPBs Workshop - Opening Statement  (13 kb .pdf)
  - GasNet - EDBs GPBs Workshop - Opening Statement  (188 kb .pdf)
  - Powerco - EDBs GPBs Workshop - Opening Statement  (265 kb .pdf)
  - PwC (on behalf of 21 EDBs) - EDBs GPBs Workshop - Opening Statement  (33 kb .pdf)
  - Unison - EDBs GPBs Workshop - Opening Statement 22 February 2010  (95 kb .pdf)
  - Vector - EDBs GPBs Workshop - Opening Statement  (409 kb .pdf)
  - EDB/GPB Additional Workshop Materials: Cost Allocation  (210 kb .pdf)
  - EDB/GPB Additional Workshop Materials: Asset Valuation Table  (29 kb .pdf)
Airports Workshop Notification (11 February 2010)  (82 kb .pdf)
  - AIAL - Airports Workshop - Opening Statement  (2008 kb .PDF)
  - Air NZ - Airports Workshop - Opening Statement  (32 kb .PDF)
  - BARNZ - Airports Workshop - Opening Statement  (30 kb .PDF)
  - CIAL - Airports Workshop - Opening Statement  (160 kb .PDF)
  - NZAA - Airports Workshop - Opening Statement  (103 kb .PDF)
  - NZAA - Airports Workshop - Asset and Cost Allocation Presentation  (1604 kb .ppt)
  - WIAL - Airports Workshop - Opening Statement  (1189 kb .PDF)
Airports Workshop - Workshop Materials (11 February 2010)  (263 kb .pdf)
Invitation for Airports Post-Workshop Submissions (22 February 2010)  (51 kb .PDF)
Input Methodologies Tax Workshop Agenda 08 February 2010  (59 kb .pdf)
Tax Workshop Notification - 8 February 2010  (20 kb .pdf)
Invitation for Tax Post-Workshop Submissions  (23 kb .PDF)
Regulatory Tax Workshop Notification  (20 kb .pdf)

Top

Emerging Views Workshops - Transcripts
Electricity Transmission Transcript - 2 March 2010  (175 kb .pdf)
Electricity Transmission Transcript - 3 March 2010  (360 kb .pdf)
Electricity Distribution & Gas Pipelines Workshop Transcript - 25 February 2010  (315 kb .pdf)
Electricity Distribution & Gas Pipelines Workshop Transcript - 24 February 2010  (332 kb .pdf)
Airports Workshop Transcript (Final) - 18 February 2010   (295 kb .pdf)
Airports Workshop Transcript (Final) - 17 February 2010  (264 kb .pdf)
WIAL Terminal Map - Tabled by BARNZ at Workshop on 18 February 2010  (183 kb .pdf)
Input Methodologies Tax Workshop Transcript - 8 February 2010  (168 kb .pdf)

Top

Electricity Distribution and Gas Pipelines Workshop - 24 - 25 February 2010 - Post-workshop Submissions
AECT - EDBs & GPBs - Post-workshop submission  (209 kb .PDF)
Aurora - EDBs & GPBs - Post-workshop submission  (547 kb .PDF)
ENA - EDBs & GPBs - Post-workshop submission  (73 kb .PDF)
  - ENA (Chapman Tripp) - Memo  (54 kb .PDF)
  - ENA (LECG) - Common Cost Allocation Issues  (66 kb .PDF)
GasNet - EDBs & GPBs - Post-Workshop Submission  (209 kb .PDF)
MDL - EDBs & GPBs - Post -workshop submission  (2848 kb .PDF)
Orion - EDBs & GPBs - Post-workshop submission  (211 kb .pdf)
Powerco - EDBs & GPBs - Post-workshop submission  (192 kb .PDF)
  - Powerco (Wilson Cook & Co Limited) - EDB Net Fixed Asset Valuations  (113 kb .PDF)
PwC (for 21 EDBs) - EDBs & GPBs - Post-workshop submission  (296 kb .PDF)
Telecom - Post-workshop submission  (297 kb .pdf)
Unison - EDBs & GPBs - Post-workshop submission  (150 kb .PDF)
  - Unison - EDBs & GPBs - Response to Commission Questions  (243 kb .PDF)
  - Unison (CRAI) - Cost Allocation and the Regulatory Asset Base  (217 kb .PDF)
WE - Post-workshop submission  (271 kb .PDF)
Vector - EDBs & GPBs - PUBLIC VERSION - Post-workshop submission  (640 kb .PDF)
  - Vector - EDBs & GPBs - PUBLIC VERSION - Response to questions  (103 kb .PDF)
  - Vector (Synergies) - EDBs & GPBs - Post-workshop submission  (585 kb .PDF)
  - Vector - ODV review concerns letter of 26 Feb 2004  (54 kb .PDF)

Top

Electricity Distribution and Gas Pipelines Workshop - 24 - 25 February 2010 - Pre-workshop Submissions
AECT - EDBs & GPBs - Cover Letter for Pre-workshop Submission - February 2010   (148 kb .pdf)
ENA - EDBs & GPBs - Cover Letter for Pre-workshop Submission - February 2010   (87 kb .pdf)
GasNet - EDBs & GPBs - Cover Letter for Pre-workshop Submission - February 2010   (200 kb .pdf)
Maui - EDBs & GPBs - Cover Letter for Pre-workshop Submission - February 2010   (152 kb .pdf)
Orion - EDBs & GPBs - Cover Letter for Pre-workshop Submission - February 2010   (150 kb .PDF)
Powerco - EDBs & GPBs - Cover Letter for Pre-workshop Submission - February 2010   (226 kb .pdf)
Powerco - EDBs & GPBs - Pre-workshop Submission February 2010  (145 kb .pdf)
PWC (on behalf 21 EDBs) - EDBs & GPBs - Pre-workshop Submission February 2010   (94 kb .pdf)
Unison - EDBs & GDBs - Pre-workshop Purpose Statement  (140 kb .pdf)
Unison - Pre-workshop submission - RAB & Cost Allocation - February 2010  (237 kb .pdf)
Unison EDBs & GPBs - cover letter - Pre-workshop Submission on RAB & Cost Allocation - February 2010  (152 kb .pdf)
Vector - EDBs & GPBs Pre-workshop Submission - February 2010  (509 kb .pdf)
Wellington Electricity - EDBs & GPBs Pre-workshop Submission - February 2010  (203 kb .pdf)

Top

Airports Workshop - 17-18 February 2010 - Post-workshop Submissions
AIAL - Airports - Post-workshop Submission  (77 kb .PDF)
  - AIAL- Statement for AIAL by Professor Kahn  (57 kb .PDF)
Air NZ - Airports - Post-workshop submission  (111 kb .PDF)
  - Air NZ (Frontier Economics) - Airports - Post-workshop submission  (221 kb .pdf)
BARNZ - Airports - Post-workshop Submission - Forecast Information Disclosure  (78 kb .pdf)
BARNZ - Airports - Post-workshop submission Part A (minus pgs 21 & 22)  (163 kb .PDF)
BARNZ - Airports - Post-workshop submission Part B (pgs 21 & 22)  (34 kb .PDF)
  - BARNZ - Athens Incentive Programme 2010  (56 kb .PDF)
  - BARNZ - Austin-Bergstrom International Incentive Program  (180 kb .PDF)
  - BARNZ - BNE Incentive Rebate  (14 kb .PDF)
  - BARNZ - Manchester rebates  (2370 kb .PDF)
  - BARNZ - Seattle Tacoma Incentive  (1156 kb .PDF)
  - BARNZ - Thailand Incentive Progamme  (139 kb .PDF)
  - BARNZ (NZIER) - Airports - Post-workshop submission  (70 kb .PDF)
  - BARNZ (Property Advisory Ltd) - Response Emerging Views Workshop  (140 kb .PDF)
  - Post Workshop Airports Submission\BARNZ (Wong) - Asset Revaluations in NZ under IFRS  (57 kb .PDF)
CIAL - Airports - Post-Workshop Submission  (1203 kb .PDF)
NZAA - Airports - Post-workshop Submission  (718 kb .PDF)
  - NZAA - Airports Asset Plan Forecast  (730 kb .PDF)
  - NZAA - Economics Joint Note  (76 kb .PDF)
  - NZAA - IM Emerging Views (Expert Valuers Report)  (273 kb .PDF)
WIAL - Aiports - Post-workshop Submission  (2652 kb .PDF)

Top

Airports Workshop - 17 & 18 February 2010 - Pre-workshop Submissions
AIAL - Airports - Pre-workshop Submission Feb 2010  (3473 kb .pdf)
Air NZ - Airports - Pre-workshop Submission Feb 2010  (262 kb .pdf)
Air NZ (Frontier Economics) - Comments on Emerging Views Paper  (443 kb .pdf)
Air NZ Appendix - 2 of 3 Downside Risks Now Crystallised  (221 kb .pdf)
Air NZ Appendix - AIAL - So Where Are You?  (237 kb .pdf)
Air NZ Appendix - Nice Guy or Guilty Conscience  (232 kb .pdf)
Air NZ Appendix - AIAL - Regulatory Quagmire  (222 kb .pdf)
Air NZ Appendix - AIAL - A change in Commerce Commission Thinking  (91 kb .pdf)
Air NZ Appendix - AIAL - A Negative Starting Point on Aeronautical Regulation  (230 kb .pdf)
Air NZ Appendix - AIAL - AIA's ROA is A-OK  (104 kb .pdf)
Air NZ Appendix - AIAL - Focus Shifting Back to Auckland  (253 kb .pdf)
Air NZ Appendix - AIAL - Poles Apart  (207 kb .pdf)
Air NZ Appendix - AIAL - Working Hard Standing Still  (250 kb .pdf)
BARNZ - Pre-workshop Submission Feb 2010  (120 kb .pdf)
BARNZ (NZIER) - Emerging Views Valuation Approach  (55 kb .pdf)
CIAL - Airports - Pre-workshop Submission Feb 2010  (444 kb .pdf)
NZAA - Airports - Pre-workshop Submission Feb 2010  (416 kb .pdf)
WIAL - Airports - Pre-workshop Submission  (338 kb .pdf)

Top

Tax Workshop - 8 February 2010 - Post-workshop Submissions
ENA - Regulatory Tax - Post-workshop submission  (677 kb .PDF)
ENA (PwC on behalf of) - Regulatory Tax - Post-workshop submission  (598 kb .PDF)
GasNet - Regulatory Tax - Post-workshop submission  (183 kb .PDF)
Powerco- Regulatory Tax - Post-workshop submission  (233 kb .PDF)
PwC (for 21 EDBs) - Regulatory Tax - Post-workshop submission  (44 kb .PDF)
Unison - Regulatory Tax - Post-workshop submission  (139 kb .PDF)
  - Unison (CRA on behalf of) - Regulatory Tax - Comparison of Deferred Tax Approaches March 2010  (372 kb .PDF)
Vector - Regulatory Tax - Post- workshop cross-submission  (118 kb .PDF)
WEL - Regulatory Tax - Post-workshop submission  (24 kb .PDF)

Top

Tax Workshop - 8 February 2010 - Pre-workshop Submissions & Comments On Workshop Process
ENA - Regulatory Tax - Comments on workshop process  (312 kb .pdf)
ENA - Regulatory Tax - Pre-workshop submission  (262 kb .pdf)
  - ENA Regulatory Tax NPV Equivalence Model Feb 10 V1.1 (discussed at Workshop)  (391 kb .xls)
GasNet - Regulatory Tax - Pre-workshop submission  (186 kb .pdf)
Powerco - Regulatory Tax - Pre-workshop submission  (232 kb .pdf)
Powerco (PwC) - Regulatory Tax - Initial Tax Base  (174 kb .pdf)
PwC (for 21 EDBs) - Regulatory Tax - Pre-workshop submission  (165 kb .pdf)
Unison - Regulatory Tax - Pre-workshop submission  (373 kb .pdf)
Unison (Andrew Shelley) - Deferred Tax Example  (209 kb .XLS)
Unison (CRA on behalf of) - Regulatory Tax - Implementing the Deferred Tax Approach  (135 kb .pdf)
Vector - Regulatory Tax - Comment on workshop process  (408 kb .pdf)
Wellington Electricity - Regulatory Tax - Comment on workshop process  (14 kb .pdf)

Top

Emerging Views Papers - 23 December 2009
Spreadsheet underlying Figures A1 and A2 of the Electricity Distribution and Gas Pipelines Emerging Views Papers  (1443 kb .zip)
Input Methodologies (Airports Services) Emerging Views Paper  (509 kb .pdf)
Input Methodologies (Electricity Distribution) Emerging Views Paper  (758 kb .pdf)
Input Methodologies (Gas Pipeline Services) Emerging Views Paper  (729 kb .pdf)

Top

Submissions on Process for Transpower
Transpower  (116 kb .pdf)

Top

Update on Process for Input Methodologies and Airports Information Disclosure
Update on Process to Determine Input Methodologies and Airports Information Disclosure Requirements  (48 kb .pdf)

Top

Update on Process for Transpower
Revised Transpower Process Paper  (63 kb .pdf)

Top

Gas - Default/Customised Price-Quality Regulation - Updated Process Paper - 9 October 2009
Updated Process Paper for Suppliers of Gas Pipeline Services  (57 kb .pdf)

Top

Cross Submissions on Information Disclosure Discussion Paper in Respect of Airport Services - 2 November 2009
1. Air New Zealand  (346 kb .pdf)
2. Auckland Airport  (110 kb .pdf)
3. Board of Airline Representatives NZ  (60 kb .pdf)
4. NZ Airports Association  (605 kb .pdf)
5. Wellington International Airport Ltd  (360 kb .pdf)

Top

Request for Cross Submissions on Information Disclosure Discussion Paper in Respect of Airport Services - 1 October 2009
Cross Submissions on Information Disclosure Discussion Paper in Respect of Airport Services  (26 kb .pdf)

Top

Questions for Cross Submissions
Questions for Cross Submissions  (114 kb .pdf)

Top

Post Input Methodologies Conference Cross-Submissions
1. Auckland Energy Consumer Trust  (287 kb .pdf)
2. Auckland International Airport Ltd - PUBLIC  (144 kb .pdf)
  - NERA (on behalf of Auckland International Airport Ltd)  (60 kb .pdf)
  - Seagers Report (on behalf of Auckland International Airport Ltd)  (71 kb .pdf)
3. Air New Zealand - PUBLIC  (179 kb .pdf)
  -  Frontier Economics (on behalf of Air New Zealand)  (201 kb .pdf)
4. Aurora Energy  (308 kb .pdf)
5. Board of Airline Representatives of New Zealand - PUBLIC  (119 kb .pdf)
  -  NZIER (on behalf of Board of Airline Representatives of New Zealand)  (70 kb .pdf)
6. Christchurch International Airport Ltd  (371 kb .pdf)
  -  PricewaterhouseCoopers (on behalf of Christchurch International Airport Ltd)  (178 kb .pdf)
7. ENA  (17 kb .pdf)
  -  PricewaterhouseCoopers (on behalf of ENA)  (214 kb .pdf)
8. GasNet  (214 kb .pdf)
9. Maui Development Ltd  (4034 kb .pdf)
10. MEUG  (40 kb .pdf)
11. New Zealand Airports Association  (569 kb .pdf)
  - LECG (on behalf of New Zealand Airports Association)  (342 kb .pdf)
  - Wareham Cameron (on behalf of New Zealand Airports Association)  (158 kb .pdf)
12. Orion  (168 kb .pdf)
  -  NERA (on behalf of Orion)  (102 kb .pdf)
13. Powerco  (297 kb .pdf)
  -  PricewaterhouseCoopers (on behalf of Powerco)   (203 kb .pdf)
14. PricewaterhouseCoopers (on behalf of 19 companies)  (127 kb .pdf)
15. Unison  (399 kb .pdf)
  - Letter from Unison  (129 kb .pdf)
16. Vector - PUBLIC  (760 kb .pdf)
  - PricewaterhouseCoopers (on behalf of Vector)   (107 kb .pdf)
  - Synergies (on behalf of Vector)   (187 kb .pdf)
17. Wellington Electricity  (276 kb .pdf)
18. Wellington International Airport Ltd.  (880 kb .pdf)

Top

Input Methodologies Conference Transcripts
Input Methodologies Conference Transcript - Airports - 15 September 2009  (473 kb .pdf)
Input Methodologies Conference Transcript - Gas Pipeline Services - 16 September 2009  (474 kb .pdf)
Input Methodologies Conference Transcript - Electricity Distribution Services - 17 September 2009  (436 kb .pdf)

Top

Information Disclosure Discussion Paper - 29 July 2009
Information Disclosure Discussion Paper - 29 July 2009  (827 kb .pdf)

Top

Submissions on Information Disclosure Discussion Paper - 29 July 2009
1. Air New Zealand  (167 kb .pdf)
2. Auckland Airport  (253 kb .pdf)
3. Board of Airline Representatives New Zealand (Inc)  (262 kb .pdf)
4. Christchurch International Airport Ltd  (180 kb .pdf)
5. Eastland Networks  (488 kb .pdf)
6. EECA  (44 kb .pdf)
7. ENA  (103 kb .pdf)
8. GasNet  (354 kb .pdf)
9. Maui  (205 kb .pdf)
10. MEUG  (77 kb .pdf)
  - Briefing Note by Strata (on behalf of MEUG)  (169 kb .pdf)
11. New Zealand Airports Association  (1089 kb .pdf)
  - Support Paper on Airport Master Planning (on behalf of NZ Airports)  (589 kb .pdf)
12. Orion  (354 kb .pdf)
13. Powerco  (504 kb .pdf)
14. PricewaterhouseCoopers  (501 kb .pdf)
15. Transpower  (184 kb .pdf)
16. Unison  (127 kb .pdf)
17 Vector  (534 kb .pdf)
18. Wellington Electricity  (215 kb .pdf)
19. Wellington International Airport Ltd  (335 kb .pdf)

Top

Input Methodologies Discussion Paper - 19 June 2009
Input Methodologies Discussion Paper  (3831 kb .pdf)

Top

Submissions on Input Methodologies Discussion Paper
Air New Zealand Ltd  (278 kb .pdf)
Auckland Energy Consumer Trust  (225 kb .pdf)
Auckland International Airport Ltd  (791 kb .pdf)
Aurora Energy  (839 kb .pdf)
Board of Airline Representatives New Zealand Inc  (375 kb .pdf)
Christchurch International Airport Ltd  (408 kb .pdf)
  - PricewaterhouseCoopers - Asset Valuation for Aeronautical Services (on behalf of Christchurch International Airport Ltd  (261 kb .pdf)
Contact Energy  (35 kb .pdf)
Eastland Network  (437 kb .pdf)
Electricity Networks Association  (167 kb .pdf)
Electricity Networks Association - Letter in Support of ENA's Submission on Input Methodologies Discussion Paper  (3831 kb .pdf)
  - PricewaterhouseCoopers - Comment on Regulatory Tax Issues (on behalf of Electricity Networks Association)  (435 kb .pdf)
  - Top Energy Letter of Support  (172 kb .pdf)
LECG - Submission attached to Input Methodologies Submission  (212 kb .pdf)
GasNet  (363 kb .pdf)
Maui  (290 kb .pdf)
MEUG  (71 kb .pdf)
  - Ireland Wallace & Associates Ltd - Input Methodologies Discussion Paper Submission (on behalf of MEUG)  (127 kb .pdf)
Mighty River Power  (194 kb .pdf)
  - Mighty River Power - Submission to the Electricity Commission on Distribution Pricing Methodology   (613 kb .pdf)
NZ Airports Association  (1090 kb .pdf)
  - LECG Report - Appendix 1 (on behalf of NZ Airports Association)  (339 kb .pdf)
  - Wareham Cameron Report - Appendix 2 (on behalf of NZ Airports Association)  (247 kb .pdf)
Orion  (245 kb .pdf)
Powerco  (622 kb .pdf)
Powerco - Letter of Support of ENA Submission on Input Methodologies paper  (136 kb .pdf)
PowerNet  (51 kb .pdf)
PricewaterhouseCoopers  (1111 kb .pdf)
Telecom  (70 kb .pdf)
The Lines Company  (50 kb .pdf)
  - Tax Payable Renewals (on behalf of The Lines Company)  (8 kb .pdf)
Vector - Cover Letter  (878 kb .pdf)
  - Capital Contribution Economic Asset Use (on behalf of The Lines Company)  (9 kb .pdf)
  - Capital Contribution Non Economic Asset Use Reserve (on behalf of The Lines Company)  (8 kb .pdf)
  - Deferred Tax (on behalf of The Lines Company)  (8 kb .pdf)
  - Capital Contribution (on behalf of The Lines Company)  (8 kb .pdf)
  - Capital Contribution Non Economic Asset Use (on behalf of The Lines Company)  (8 kb .pdf)
Transpower  (452 kb .pdf)
  - Transpower Covering Letter  (52 kb .pdf)
Unison  (156 kb .pdf)
  - Castalia - Input Methodologies Economic Issues (on behalf of Unison)  (175 kb .pdf)
  - CRA - Input Methodologies Economic Issues - (on behalf of Unison)  (282 kb .pdf)
  - Appendix (on behalf of Unison)  (622 kb .pdf)
  - Robert Cameron (on behalf of Unison)  (48 kb .pdf)
Vector  (1043 kb .pdf)
  - Synergies Economics Expert Statement  (675 kb .pdf)
  - Vector's Response to Commerce Commission's Questions  (158 kb .pdf)
  - Synergies Economics WACC Report  (562 kb .pdf)
  - PwC - Taxation Issues - Submission on the Draft Authorisation for Vector's controlled Gas Business  (405 kb .pdf)
Wellington Electricity Ltd  (471 kb .pdf)
Wellington International Airport Ltd  (3132 kb .pdf)

Top

Cross Submissions on Input Methodologies Discussion Paper
1. Air New Zealand  (71 kb .pdf)
  - Frontier Economics - Input Methodologies Discussion Paper (on behalf of Air New Zealand)  (215 kb .pdf)
2. Auckland International Airport Limited  (139 kb .pdf)
3. Aurora Energy  (574 kb .pdf)
4. Board of Airline Representatives New Zealand Inc  (119 kb .pdf)
  - NZIER - Input Methodologies Discussion Paper (on behalf of Board of Airline Representatives New Zealand Inc)  (75 kb .pdf)
5. Christchurch International Airport Limited  (520 kb .pdf)
6. ENA  (977 kb .pdf)
7. Maui  (324 kb .pdf)
8. MEUG  (20 kb .pdf)
  - Ireland Wallace & Associates Limited - Input Methodologies Discussion Paper Cross Submission (on behalf of MEUG)  (62 kb .pdf)
9. NZ Airports Association  (3139 kb .pdf)
10. Powerco  (805 kb .pdf)
11. Unison  (180 kb .pdf)
12. Vector  (331 kb .pdf)
  - Synergies Economics WACC Report (on behalf of Vector)  (990 kb .pdf)
  - Vector - Additional Information for Vector’s Cross Submission on the Input Methodologies Discussion paper  (149 kb .pdf)
13. Wellington International Airport Limited  (1666 kb .pdf)
14. Joint NERA/PwC Report: Initial Value of Regulatory Assets - The Australian Experience  (474 kb .pdf)

Top

Revised Draft Guidelines on the Cost of Capital Paper - 19 June 2009
Revised Draft Guidelines on the Cost of Capital Paper  (522 kb .pdf)

Top

Submissions on Revised Draft Guidelines on the Cost of Capital Paper
1. Auckland Airport  (45 kb .pdf)
2. Christchurch International Airport  (1174 kb .pdf)
3. Eastland Network  (136 kb .pdf)
4. ENA - Report from LECG  (212 kb .pdf)
5. MEUG - Report from Ireland and Wallace  (127 kb .pdf)
6. NZ Airports Association - Report from LECG  (339 kb .pdf)
7. Powerco - from PricewaterhouseCoopers - Revised Draft Guidelines (on behalf of Powerco)  (247 kb .pdf)
  - PWC letter (on behalf of Powerco)  (42 kb .pdf)
8. PricewaterhouseCoopers  (323 kb .pdf)
9. Telecom  (79 kb .pdf)
  - Annex B (Telecom)  (59 kb .pdf)
  - Graeme Guthrie (on behalf of Telecom)  (83 kb .pdf)
10. Unison  (3701 kb .pdf)
  - Report from Castalia (Alex Sundakov)  (175 kb .pdf)
11. Vector Submission on WACC  (562 kb .pdf)

Top

Submissions on Transpower Process and Recommendation Paper
MEUG  (24 kb .pdf)
PricewaterhouseCoopers  (178 kb .pdf)
Transpower Submission  (53 kb .pdf)
Transpower - Response to Questions  (451 kb .pdf)

Top

Cross Submissions on Revised Draft Guidelines on the Cost of Capital Paper - 19 June 2009
1. ENA  (977 kb .pdf)
2. Marlborough Lines  (114 kb .pdf)
  - e-dec Limited - Comments on the Commerce Commission's Approach to Estimating the Cost of Capital (on behalf of Marlborough Lines)  (88 kb .pdf)
3. MEUG  (20 kb .pdf)
  - Ireland Wallace & Associates Limited - Input Methodologies Discussion Paper Cross Submission (on behalf of MEUG)  (62 kb .pdf)
4. Powerco  (805 kb .pdf)
5. Telecom  (57 kb .pdf)
6. Unison  (180 kb .pdf)
7. Vector - Additional Information for Vector’s Cross Submission on the Input Methodologies Discussion paper  (149 kb .pdf)
  - Synergies Economics WACC Report (on behalf of Vector)  (988 kb .pdf)

Top

Transpower Process and Recommendation Paper - 19 June 2009
Transpower Process and Recommendation Discussion Paper - 19 June 2009  (273 kb .pdf)

Top

Gas - Default/Customised Price-Quality Regulation - 24 July 2009
Gas - Default/Customised Price-Quality Regulation  (59 kb .pdf)

Top

Submissions on Gas - Default/Customised Price-Quality Regulation - 24 July 2009
GasNet  (206 kb .pdf)
Maui Development Ltd  (337 kb .pdf)
Powerco  (317 kb .pdf)
Vector Ltd  (154 kb .pdf)

Top

Part 4 Discussion Documents
1. Input Methodologies Discussion Paper 19 June 2009  (3831 kb .pdf)
  - Farrier Swier FINAL Report - Treatment of Expenditure in CPPs 03 June 2009  (1089 kb .pdf)
2. Revised Draft Guidelines on the Cost of Capital 19 June 2009  (522 kb .pdf)
  - Expert Panel Report  (333 kb .pdf)
3. Transpower Process and Recommendation Discussion Paper - 19 June 2009  (273 kb .pdf)
4. Reset of DPP for EDBs - Discussion Paper - 19 June 2009  (1152 kb .pdf)
  - Economic Insights - Asset Valuation and Productivity-based Regulation - 19 June 2009  (425 kb .pdf)
  - Economic Insights - Regulation Technical Report - 19 June 2009  (850 kb .pdf)
5. Gas - Default/Customised Price-Quality Regulation  (59 kb .pdf)
6. Information Disclosure Discussion Paper - 29 July 2009  (827 kb .pdf)

Top

Cost of Capital Discussion Documents
BL versus Classical CAPM  (26 kb .xls)
Cost of Capital Straw Person Example  (180 kb .pdf)
Effects of Leverage on WACC Under Two Different CAPMs  (60 kb .pdf)
WACC and Leverage - A Note by Dr Martin Lally  (40 kb .pdf)

Top

Cost of Capital Workshop Documents
Cost of Capital Workshop - 12 November 2009  (405 kb .pdf)
Cost of Capital Workshop - 13 November 2009  (393 kb .pdf)
Cost of Capital - Invitations for Submissions  (30 kb .pdf)

Top

Submissions on Cost of Capital Workshop
Auckland Energy Consumer Trust - Cross-Submission on WACC Workshop  (461 kb .PDF)
Auckland International Airport Ltd - WACC cross-submission  (25 kb .PDF)
Board of Airlines Representatives NZ - Submission on Cost of Capital  (179 kb .PDF)
  -  NZIER - Submission on Cost of Capital  (2271 kb .PDF)
Electricity Networks Association - Cross submission on cost of capital  (95 kb .PDF)
Maui Development Ltd - Cross-submission on the Cost of Capital Workshop  (306 kb .PDF)
MEUG - Post-workshop submission on draft cost of capital guidelines  (21 kb .pdf)
  -  Ireland Wallace & Asssociates - Post-Workshop Submission on Cost of Capital  (46 kb .PDF)
NZ Airports - WACC Workshop Submission  (567 kb .pdf)
  -  Dr Marsden - Comments on the Commissions Approach to Cost of Capital  (653 kb .PDF)
Powerco (PwC) - Cross submission on WACC conference  (346 kb .PDF)
Pricewaterhouse Coopers - Group Cross Submission (on Behalf of 17 EDBs) on the Cost of Capital Workshop  (122 kb .pdf)
Telecom - Cost of capital post-workshop submission  (73 kb .PDF)
  -  Antony Srzich - Comparing the tilted annuity and the building blocks approach to the risk free rate  (60 kb .PDF)
  -  Graeme Guthrie - WACC Guidelines  (120 kb .PDF)
  -  Pricewaterhouse Coopers - Cost of Capital Workshop Submission  (208 kb .PDF)
Transpower - Cross Submission on WACC workshop  (362 kb .PDF)
Unison - Cost of Capital Cross Submission  (378 kb .PDF)
  -  CRA Report - Leverage and the Cost of Capital  (238 kb .PDF)
Vector - Cross-submission on cost of capital workshop  (603 kb .PDF)
  -  Synergies Report - Cross-submission on cost of capital workshop  (329 kb .PDF)
Wellington Electricity - Post WACC Workshop Cross Submission  (259 kb .PDF)

Top

Download Acrobat Reader Print
Top